Time to take a much-needed break from the woes of the O’s and actually address the biggest sports news of the weekend: the NFL Draft.
You can get plenty of draft analysis from every newspaper and sports website in the country, so I’ll leave the obvious stuff to the “experts.” I’m more interested in ranking by the intangibles, the things that don’t show up in a box score. More often than not that’s how you really know.
So here’s a completely fresh take on the hometown division — who did what, how they did, and why it either rules or doesn’t.
In order from best to worst:
1. Cleveland Browns
Taking a lineman in the first round is a boring move. Big fat guys, and especially big fat white guys, just don’t often excite. Sensing this, Phil Savage and company made it go down a little easier by selecting a lineman who eschewed New York pageantry in favor of a fishing trip, ESPN cameras in tow. Nice.
Then they traded up late in the first round to get Brady Quinn, who is going to be a beast in this league. How do I know that? He’s (a) handsome, (b) played at Notre Dame (which is due to place another star quarterback in the league), and (c) has “Brady” in his name. The Browns not only win, they win big.
2. Pittsburgh Steelers
There’s a huge dropoff after the Browns, and so really in a sense the other teams all tied for fourth. But if one team stands out among them, it’s the Steelers. Why? Because they traded up in the fourth round to draft a punter. A left-footed punter. And a punter with a bit of a streak, too. Even though the Steelers still have veteran Chris Gardocki on the roster, this is what the kid had to say about whether or not he’d be starting in year one:
“I think the fourth round sends a pretty strong message. I also recognize that if you don’t get the job done, you won’t be the guy.”
They also got a fellow named Ryan McBean, and in doing so removed all doubt that the number two spot is theirs.
3. Baltimore Ravens
For the most part, the Ravens did what the Ravens do: bored the shit out of their fans and everybody else with a bunch of boring picks, half of whom will eventually end up being productive NFL players. But there was a bit of intrigue.
Having tried and failed to pull off a trade for the chance to draft Quinn, they made the single most head-scratching move of the draft: Troy Smith in the fifth round.
Smith is a marginal NFL prospect at best, a guy whose only chance at success would be to go to a team and a system with a history of great quarterback development. Instead he ends up with the Ravens, an organization that goes out of their way to crush the soul of every young quarterback they can find. In other words, a Worst Case Scenario.
The only winner here is Drew Olson. He’s surely going to be the odd man out, which means that he’ll be leaving Baltimore before Billick’s reverse Midas touch can permanently take hold.
4. Cincinnatti Bengals
I actually had to go to the Cincinnatti Enquirer to confirm that the Bengals did, in fact, participate in this year’s draft. Not only did they participate, they completely let us down. Out of a college class surely teeming with questionable characters the Bengals went and got Leon Hall, a guy who by all accounts is a fine citizen. Frankly I expected better.
They did end up with a guy named Chinedum Ndukwe in the seventh round, but that’s not enough to salvage an otherwise underwhelming performance.
Given that draft classes tend to only make sense two or three years down the road, look for the above rankings to also be the finishing order for the 2009 season. And remember you heard it here first.